tracker issue : CF-4205069

select a category, or use search below
(searches all categories and all time range)
Title:

[ANeff] Bug for: Pre-CF2018 vs CF2018 w.r.t. Array Case/NoCase searching of simple values

| View in Tracker

Status/Resolution/Reason: Open//

Reporter/Name(from Bugbase): Aaron N. / ()

Created: 08/28/2019

Components: Language, Functions

Versions: 2018

Failure Type: Data Corruption

Found In Build/Fixed In Build: 2018.0.04.314546 /

Priority/Frequency: Normal / Some users will encounter

Locale/System: / Windows 10 64 bit

Vote Count: 0

Issue: Pre-CF2018 (CF10/CF11/CF2016) vs CF2018 w.r.t. Array Case/NoCase searching of simple values

CF2018 breaks backward-compat w.r.t. searching some simple values in arrays.

Note: Please ignore if this is a duplicate. I reported this during public beta but I can't seem to find a ticket about it.

Repro:

Comment out each 'haystack' variable, then compare result on CF2016 and CF2018.

<cfscript>
  columnList = "acfBuild,acfFunction,stringTrue,booleanTrue,numberOne,stringFalse,booleanFalse,numberZero";
  result = queryNew(columnList);
  acfBuild = SERVER.ColdFusion.productVersion;
  
  haystack = [1,"true",true,0,"false",false];//try this
  
  //haystack = [true,false];//then try this
  
  needles = [{type="stringTrue", value="true"}, {type="booleanTrue", value=true}, {type="numberOne", value=1}, {type="stringFalse", value="false"}, {type="booleanFalse", value=false}, {type="numberZero", value=0}];
  functionNames = ["arrayFind","arrayFindNoCase","arrayFindAll","arrayFindAllNoCase","arrayContains","arrayContainsNoCase","arrayDelete","arrayDeleteNoCase"];
  for(functionName in functionNames) {
	  rowToAdd = {acfBuild=acfBuild, acfFunction='#functionName#()'};
	  for(needle in needles) {
		  try {rowToAdd[needle.type] = evaluate("#functionName#(duplicate(haystack), needle.value)");}
		  catch(any e) {rowToAdd[needle.type] = e.message;}
		  if(isArray(rowToAdd[needle.type])) {
			  rowToAdd[needle.type] = arrayToList(rowToAdd[needle.type]);
		  }
	  }
	  result.addRow(rowToAdd);
  }
  writeDump(result);
</cfscript>

Actual and Expected Result on CF2016:

With 1st haystack enabled:

query
  	acfBuild 	acfFunction 	booleanFalse 	booleanTrue 	numberOne 	numberZero 	stringFalse 	stringTrue
1 	2016,0,01,298513 	arrayFind() 	4 	1 	1 	4 	4 	1
2 	2016,0,01,298513 	arrayFindNoCase() 	4 	1 	1 	4 	4 	1
3 	2016,0,01,298513 	arrayFindAll() 	4,5,6 	1,2,3 	1,2,3 	4,5,6 	4,5,6 	1,2,3
4 	2016,0,01,298513 	arrayFindAllNoCase() 	4,5,6 	1,2,3 	1,2,3 	4,5,6 	4,5,6 	1,2,3
5 	2016,0,01,298513 	arrayContains() 	YES 	YES 	YES 	YES 	YES 	YES
6 	2016,0,01,298513 	arrayContainsNoCase() 	YES 	YES 	YES 	YES 	YES 	YES
7 	2016,0,01,298513 	arrayDelete() 	YES 	YES 	YES 	YES 	YES 	YES
8 	2016,0,01,298513 	arrayDeleteNoCase() 	YES 	YES 	YES 	YES 	YES 	YES 

With 2nd haystack enabled:

query
  	acfBuild 	acfFunction 	booleanFalse 	booleanTrue 	numberOne 	numberZero 	stringFalse 	stringTrue
1 	2016,0,01,298513 	arrayFind() 	2 	1 	1 	2 	2 	1
2 	2016,0,01,298513 	arrayFindNoCase() 	2 	1 	1 	2 	2 	1
3 	2016,0,01,298513 	arrayFindAll() 	2 	1 	1 	2 	2 	1
4 	2016,0,01,298513 	arrayFindAllNoCase() 	2 	1 	1 	2 	2 	1
5 	2016,0,01,298513 	arrayContains() 	YES 	YES 	YES 	YES 	YES 	YES
6 	2016,0,01,298513 	arrayContainsNoCase() 	YES 	YES 	YES 	YES 	YES 	YES
7 	2016,0,01,298513 	arrayDelete() 	YES 	YES 	YES 	YES 	YES 	YES
8 	2016,0,01,298513 	arrayDeleteNoCase() 	YES 	YES 	YES 	YES 	YES 	YES 

Actual and Unexpected Result on CF2018:

With 1st haystack enabled:

query
  	acfBuild 	acfFunction 	booleanFalse 	booleanTrue 	numberOne 	numberZero 	stringFalse 	stringTrue
1 	2018,0,04,314546 	arrayFind() 	5 	2 	1 	4 	4 	1
2 	2018,0,04,314546 	arrayFindNoCase() 	5 	2 	1 	4 	4 	1
3 	2018,0,04,314546 	arrayFindAll() 	5,6 	2,3 	1,2 	4,5 	4,5,6 	1,2,3
4 	2018,0,04,314546 	arrayFindAllNoCase() 	5,6 	2,3 	1,2 	4,5 	4,5,6 	1,2,3
5 	2018,0,04,314546 	arrayContains() 	YES 	YES 	YES 	YES 	YES 	YES
6 	2018,0,04,314546 	arrayContainsNoCase() 	YES 	YES 	YES 	YES 	YES 	YES
7 	2018,0,04,314546 	arrayDelete() 	YES 	YES 	YES 	YES 	YES 	YES
8 	2018,0,04,314546 	arrayDeleteNoCase() 	YES 	YES 	YES 	YES 	YES 	YES 

With 2nd haystack enabled:

query
  	acfBuild 	acfFunction 	booleanFalse 	booleanTrue 	numberOne 	numberZero 	stringFalse 	stringTrue
1 	2018,0,04,314546 	arrayFind() 	2 	1 	0 	0 	2 	1
2 	2018,0,04,314546 	arrayFindNoCase() 	2 	1 	0 	0 	2 	1
3 	2018,0,04,314546 	arrayFindAll() 	2 	1 	[empty string] 	[empty string] 	2 	1
4 	2018,0,04,314546 	arrayFindAllNoCase() 	2 	1 	[empty string] 	[empty string] 	2 	1
5 	2018,0,04,314546 	arrayContains() 	YES 	YES 	NO 	NO 	YES 	YES
6 	2018,0,04,314546 	arrayContainsNoCase() 	YES 	YES 	NO 	NO 	YES 	YES
7 	2018,0,04,314546 	arrayDelete() 	YES 	YES 	NO 	NO 	YES 	YES
8 	2018,0,04,314546 	arrayDeleteNoCase() 	YES 	YES 	NO 	NO 	YES 	YES 

This reveals that all these functions are searching some of the values incorrectly.

Please ensure the fix applies to all these functions.

CF's auto-casting ensures the silent 'data corruption' aspect of this issue.

Attachments:

Comments: